Eyeko Black Magic Mascara

You may remember how excited I was about the Eyeko Skinny Mini Duo. Eyeko has added another mascara to their squeeze line, Eyeko Black Magic Mascara ($24). This version combines drama, volume and curl with an extreme black glossy finish. 

The formula is a unique water resistant gel that combines Keratin and Shea butter to condition lashes long lasting staying power. This paraben-free gel doesn’t flake or smudge and provides a super black rich color.

The brush is curved at a 90 degree angle to curl lashes and coat each lash evenly for no clumps. The bristles are plastic (my favorite kind) and are just the right size–not too big and unwieldy and not too skinny which allows for good definition.


  • Glossy deep black color
  • Nice brush
  • Good curl


  • Lacking in the volume department
  • A bit pricey for a former drugstore line

Bottom Line: If you like curl, definition and a rich black color, give Eyeko Black Magic Mascara a try. If you are looking for more drama and volume, you may want to look elsewhere.

Subscribe to A Girl’s Gotta Spa! for more beauty reviews! Watch our reviews on YouTube. Got a Kindle? We’re on Kindle too!


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Posted on by Cindy in beauty, Makeup, mascara 1 Comment

About the author


Hello I’m Cindy, editor of Prime Beauty, a beauty blog for women 40 & over and in the prime of their lives! Women over 40 have unique issues and Prime Beauty addresses those issues with information and products geared specifically for them. Prime Beauty is packed with articles on skincare, makeup, product reviews, new product launches, makeup tips and tricks, and giveaways! In addition to looking good on the outside, I hope to encourage, inspire and celebrate women over 40!

One Response to Eyeko Black Magic Mascara

  1. MarciaF (beauty info zone)

    I’ve tried the Eyeko Skinny and I really like that one.

Add a Comment